Homemade Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce Recipe

Homemade Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce Recipe

This Coney Island hot dog sauce is packed full of flavor and will make your basic hot dogs reach another level of deliciousness.

Ingredients

  • olive oil
    2 tbsp
  • ground beef
    1 lb
  • onion

    finely chopped

    1 large
  • chili powder
    2 tbsp
  • salt
    ½ tsp
  • ground allspice
    ¼ tsp
  • ground mustard
    ¼ tsp
  • garlic powder
    ½ tsp
  • ground cumin
    ⅛ tsp
  • ground cinnamon
    ⅛ tsp
  • freshly ground black pepper
    ⅛ tsp
  • cayenne pepper
    ⅛ tsp
  • tomato paste
    ¼ c
  • water
    2 c
  • hot dogs
    12
  • hot dog buns
    12
  • onions

    finely chopped

    2 large
  • prepared yellow mustard to taste
  • optional: shredded cheddar to cheese

Directions

  1. 1

    In a medium-sized pot or pan, cook the ground beef until browned. Drain excess liquids

  2. 2

    Add the chopped onions

  3. 3

    Measure your spices and mix them into the ground meat and onions

  4. 4

    Next, add your tomato paste, salt, and pepper

  5. 5

    Lastly, add 2 cups of water and simmer for 1-2 hrs depending on how you like your meat sauce. Coney Island hot dog sauce is supposed to be a bit runny

Homemade Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce Recipe

Homemade Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce Recipe

Similar Recipes

Homemade Hot Sauce

Homemade Hot Sauce

A quick and easy, non-fermented hot sauce using whatever red hot pepper you have. Similar to Frank's Red Hot Sauce or Sriracha. Recipe modified slightly Sept, 2023.

35 minutes100 servings3 kcal
Sourdough Hot Dog Buns

Sourdough Hot Dog Buns

Sourdough Hot Dog Buns are soft, sturdy, and naturally fermented with 100% sourdough. They toast up beautifully and hold up to all your favorite toppings—no soggy buns here. Perfect for summer cookouts or a simple weeknight dinner!

21 hours10 servings334 kcal
Homemade BBQ Sauce

Homemade BBQ Sauce

Homemade BBQ sauce is easier than you might think. With ketchup, vinegar, spices, and brown sugar, you can adjust the flavor of the sauce to match what you like.

35 minutes2 servings
Homemade Sauce

Homemade Sauce

When were talking about homemade meals, the first thing that comes to mind is you sitting at the dinner table with your family, Enjoying your parents delicious cooking. My friends here it is, That feeling when you'd have your parents homemade sauce dipping the bread into it and just feasting on that spectacular blend of spices is here. This dish is truly one of my favorites and my kids LOVE it. The flavors and different blend of ingredients make this dish something that I want to pass down for as long as I live. I used to make this every Sunday for my family and they would love it. I promise you, this dish will make you come back for more the next week. So don't forget to save this dish for later when you're craving it again.

7 hours
Homemade BBQ Sauce

Homemade BBQ Sauce

This Homemade BBQ Sauce is thick, sweet, smoky and a little spicy! It's big on flavor and pairs well with chicken, pork, beef or anything on your grill!

25 minutes16 servings
Coney Dog with Texas Chili

Coney Dog with Texas Chili

What more could you ask for on game day than a classic Coney dog topped with really good, authentic Texas-style chili?

120 minutes0 servings
Homemade Ketchup

Homemade Ketchup

Mm mm, nothing is better than homemade ketchup; making your own ketchup is so EASY to make at home and making it yourself allows you to control what goes in it.

25 minutes
Homemade Tartar Sauce

Homemade Tartar Sauce

This homemade tartar sauce is too easy! Prepare it for every seafood dinner, or serve it along with the best seafood appetizers. It’s creamy, tart, and so full of flavor. You’re going to love it!

10 minutes24 servings63 kcal

Ratings & Reviews

Be the First to Rate

Your rating helps others discover amazing recipes. Share your experience and let others know what you think!

About this Recipe

Craving that iconic, savory flavor of a classic Coney Island hot dog right from your own kitchen? This homemade Coney Island hot dog sauce recipe delivers a deeply satisfying taste that will elevate your everyday hot dogs from simple to extraordinary. Forget bland, watery versions; this sauce is packed with a rich, aromatic blend that truly makes your basic hot dogs reach another level of deliciousness.

The magic in this Coney Island hot dog sauce lies in its robust spice blend, which transforms humble ground beef into a flavor powerhouse. You'll find a symphony of savory notes from chili powder, garlic powder, and ground mustard, beautifully balanced with the warm undertones of allspice, cumin, and cinnamon. It’s this meticulous combination that creates the complex, crave-worthy profile synonymous with authentic Coney Island hot dogs.

When you ladle this sauce over your hot dog, you can expect a hearty, meaty topping that clings perfectly to the bun. The texture is rich and substantial, providing a satisfying counterpoint to the snap of a grilled hot dog. Each bite will bring a burst of savory, spiced beef that's incredibly comforting and reminiscent of your favorite roadside stand. It’s a dish designed for pure, unadulterated comfort food enjoyment, perfect for a casual family dinner or a backyard gathering.

Customizing your Coney Island experience is easy. While hot dogs and buns are essential, you can adjust the heat level by adding a touch more cayenne pepper, or dial it back for a milder sauce. Don't forget the classic toppings: finely chopped fresh onions provide a crucial crisp bite and pungent freshness, while a generous zigzag of prepared yellow mustard adds a tangy counterpoint. For an extra layer of indulgence, a sprinkle of shredded cheddar cheese melts into gooey perfection.

This homemade Coney Island hot dog sauce is ideal for casual weeknight dinners, game day feasts, or any occasion where you want to serve up a crowd-pleasing, flavor-packed meal that truly hits the spot.

Frequently Asked Questions